There's still time to push for stronger river protections in St. Paul

St. Paul skyline with river

St. Paul residents can sign our petition below, send a letter or come to a meeting to push city leaders for vital riverfront protections.

As St. Paul attempts to water down its proposed riverfront development regulations, residents are speaking up.

The city's new Mississippi River Corridor Critical Area (MRCCA) ordinance has the potential to protect St. Paul riverfront ecology, character and scenic views. Unfortunately, Mayor Carter’s staff has proposed an ordinance that won’t achieve those goals as well as a prior draft did.

The most recent draft removes bird-friendly building requirements and muddies the formerly straightforward standards for building heights. City staff have not offered full explanations for the proposed changes, particularly not for the changes to the building height requirements, which make the ordinance much more confusing and harder to enact.

St. Paul residents advocate for a better ordinance

Hundreds of FMR River Guardians have sent in letters or signed a petition to ask the city to improve the ordinance. And a dozen St. Paul residents, including River Guardians, took to the mic at a recent planning commission meeting. Several of the speakers were former St. Paul councilmembers or staff with many years of expertise in writing good ordinances. 

Here's what river advocates said:

Bird-friendly building is a responsibility

Residents pointed out how effectively bird-friendly building materials can protect the millions of birds that migrate along the Mississippi River through the city every year.

One speaker noted, "There's an extinction crisis right now, and it's such a simple thing that could be done that could make a huge difference... The citizens of St. Paul and the river communities really appreciate the natural corridor, and we want to see development that protects the environment and harmonizes with the river."

Clarity is key

Speakers also noted how the vague, subjective criteria for variances, conditional use permits and building heights does not meet the city’s own standards for clear ordinance language.

One resident said, "Well-written zoning ordinances avoid vague language in order to deter legal challenges and simplify administration." He remarked that the updated draft ordinance is missing details, resulting in an ordinance that would be more difficult to administer.

Window for improvements still open

Some commissioners seemed to agree with residents. Said one, “The compromise in front of us is insufficient.” Another added that bird population collapse “is an urgent matter."

That's heartening, but we still don't know if the planning commission will address the rollbacks. Their task is to continue discussions at future meetings and then send a recommended version to the city council for its approval. Mayor Carter must sign the final bill, as well.

That means we still have a window to continue to push for stronger riverfront rules, particularly with the city council and mayor.

FMR and our partners have been reaching out to councilmembers and Mayor Carter to discuss the ordinance. We appreciate Council President Rebecca Noecker’s participation in a Ward 2 constituent meeting about MRCCA co-hosted by FMR and the West Side Community Organization. 

Group of people in FMR office

Council President Rebecca Noecker met with over 25 of her constituents at FMR’s office to discuss the MRCCA ordinance.

We’ve also requested public meetings with Councilmember Jost and Mayor Carter so they can hear from their residents about their priorities for the Mississippi River. We hope they will accept the invitation to meet with their constituents. 

We’ll be sure to let our St. Paul River Guardians know when the city schedules the next meetings about the ordinance (sign up below). In the meantime, St. Paul residents can still sign FMR’s petition and write to their councilmember to let them know why good riverfront rules matter.

What St. Paul residents can do

Sign the petition

 

Send a letter to St. Paul decisionmakers

You can use the form below to send a message to your city council member. The language provided is just a starting point. Please personalize it to share your own connection to the river and why this issue is important to you. 

 

Speak at a public hearing

We'll also email all St. Paul River Guardians when the city council sets its public hearing date, which will be an opportunity for residents to speak directly to the council. Council meetings are usually on Wednesday afternoons.

Check out our quick tips or contact Grassroots Organizing Coordinator Maddie Miller at mmiller@fmr.org if you would like help preparing a 1-2 minute comment to read aloud.

 

Join a meeting with a councilmember

FMR is requesting meetings with Mayor Carter and some city council members. As these are scheduled, we'll invite supporters who live in their wards to join us. Sign up as a River Guardian (and be sure to include your street address) so we can let you know if we schedule a meeting with your elected officials.

Upcoming Events

Monday, July 7, 2025 - 6:30pm to 7:30pm
Zoom webinar
April through October
St. Paul
Saturday, July 26, 2025 - 1:00pm to 5:00pm
Hidden Falls Regional Park, St. Paul

Our River Campaign:
It all starts here

At the heart of this new campaign is the vision of a healthy Mississippi River.